Comedy
The Way They Were | Nadine Coyle and Jesse Metcalfe with Ur Welcome America!
Each week comedians Grainne Maguire and Chantal Feduchin-Pate take a deep dive into a celebrity breakup, chosen by a special guest, that still lingers in their hearts and minds.
The Way They Were
Published 07 July 2026
The Way They Were / W!ZARD Studios

The podcast where every celebrity split is the one that got away. Each week comedians Grainne Maguire and Chantal Feduchin-Pate take a deep dive into a celebrity breakup, chosen by a special guest, that still lingers in their hearts and minds. They might uncouple ‘amicably with love and respect for one another’ - but we never get over these lost loves!

You can't mistake their biology! This week on The Way They Were, Chantal and Gráinne are joined by Ben Anderson and Frazer York from Ur Welcome America to unpack the on-again, off-again romance between Girls Aloud icon Nadine Coyle and Desperate Housewives HUNK Jesse Metcalfe.

Expect noughties nostalgia, Hollywood gossip, plenty of false starts, and a relationship that proved love isn't always Something Kinda Ooooh.

[audio audio="https://rss.art19.com/episodes/40b768c7-c45f-40f0-b839-cf6ad35d698e.mp3" title="Nadine Coyle and Jesse Metcalfe" descr=""]

Hot in Comedy